More photos and scanned documents will be posted shortly.
MY FIRST POINT: Value Remodeling lies to the Better Business Bureau:



These are photos of the windows he measured and replaced, and the huge hole in the ceiling. Did Value Remodeling not see the huge hole and the water stains? Note the sun shinning through the ceiling when the subcontractors removed the shingles and rotten plywood.
MY SECOND POINT: Flashing is always replaced with a new roof. The Value Remodeling subcontractors didn't replace any flashing:
MY THIRD POINT: Who pays $$$ to replace roof shingles and ignores the leaking roof issue?:

Value Remodeling is charging me to fix their mistake:

Who are you kidding? Then again, if you were on the site supervising the job you would have seen them make these mistakes:

LAST POINT: Value Remodeling charges my credit card without my authorization, approval, and against my wishes.

Because of Value Remodeling's terrible work, bad communication, and poor quality, I had to file complaints with the Better Business Bureau and Consumer's Affairs. My advise is to hire someone else. Value Remodeling will never get my recommendation.